Skip to content
PREP
EN
Notify me

Spaghetti alla carbonara

Four ingredients, zero margin for error

Spaghetti alla carbonara
AI-generated photo.
In all
22min
Hands-on
12min
Waiting
10min
You save With the steps in parallel, instead of one at a time.
−17min

Difficulty: 3 of 5. 955 kcal each

7

sources compared

See them

The median

The quantities are the median of the versions that give them, not one person’s opinion.

The time

The sources 25min

The plan 22min

3 of 7 sources state a time: all 25min.

3

points where the sources disagree

Read them
2 people

Ingredients · 2 people

  • Spaghetti 200 g
  • Guanciale 120 g
  • Egg yolks 3
  • Pecorino romano 60 g
  • Black pepper to taste
  • Salt to taste

The plan

22min, 12min of it hands-on.

for 2 · one cook · one pan and two pots

  1. 01 Put the water on waiting, minutes 0–10
  2. 02 Cut the guanciale hands-on, minutes 0–5
  3. 03 Mix yolks and pecorino hands-on, minutes 5–9
  4. 04 Cook the pasta waiting, minutes 10–19
  5. 05 Crisp the guanciale watching, minutes 11–19
  6. 06 Mantecatura hands-on, minutes 19–22
  • hands-on
  • watching
  • waiting

The plan is for one cook, with one pan and two pots: PREP lines the steps up side by side.

The steps

  1. 01 Put the water on

    waiting · 10min · minutes 0–10

    Big pot, plenty of water, lid on.

    • A litre of water for every hundred grams of pasta.
    • Don't salt it yet: salted water takes longer to come to the boil.
    • The lid halves the time.

    IT’S READY WHEN A rolling boil that moves the whole surface, not little bubbles at the edges.

  2. 02 Cut the guanciale

    hands-on · 5min · minutes 0–5

    Strips half a centimetre thick.

    • Remove the rind but don't throw it away: whole in the pan, it perfumes the fat.
    • Thick, not thin: they need to stay soft inside and crisp outside.
    • Guanciale, not pancetta: it's fattier, and that fat is half the sauce.
    • It looks like a lot because it is: it loses nearly half its weight as it renders.

    IT’S READY WHEN Every piece the same size, so they cook evenly.

  3. 03 Mix yolks and pecorino

    hands-on · 4min · minutes 5–9

    Yolks, finely grated pecorino, freshly ground pepper.

    • One yolk per person plus one: that last one belongs to the pan.
    • Yolks only. The white is water and proteins that scramble sooner.
    • Grate it as finely as you can or the cream stays grainy.
    • The egg stays nearly raw: use pasteurised eggs for children, the elderly, or during pregnancy.

    IT’S READY WHEN A thick cream that coats the back of the spoon.

  4. 04 Cook the pasta

    waiting · 9min · minutes 10–19

    Salt the water, drop the pasta, set aside a ladle of the cooking water.

    • Go light on the salt: pecorino and guanciale are salty enough already.
    • Set the cooking water aside before you drain. Always.
    • Drain a minute before the time on the packet: it finishes in the cream.

    IT’S READY WHEN Properly al dente: bite a strand and the core is still pale.

  5. 05 Crisp the guanciale

    watching · 8min · minutes 11–19

    Cold pan, medium-low heat, no added fat.

    • Start with a cold pan: the fat renders instead of burning.
    • No oil — the guanciale releases its own, and that's what you'll need later.
    • If it sizzles hard, turn the heat down right away.

    IT’S READY WHEN Clear fat and amber edges. If they turn brown you've gone too far.

  6. 06 Mantecatura

    hands-on · 3min · tricky · minutes 19–22

    Heat off. Pasta into the guanciale first, then the cream with the pan off the hob.

    • The yolk starts to set at 63 °C and is solid at 70 °C: below 65 °C the cream won't scramble, but the egg stays nearly raw.
    • Move the pan off the heat and wait for the sizzling to stop.
    • If you're afraid of blowing it, tip everything into a steel bowl: there's no heat underneath.
    • Cooking water a little at a time, until it turns glossy.
    • Toss the pasta by moving the pan, don't stir with a spoon.

    IT’S READY WHEN Cream that slides across the plate. If it dries out, more cooking water.

Where the sources disagree

  1. 1

    Yolks or whole eggs

    Today's recipes use yolks only, one per person plus one; whole eggs and cream are the carbonara of the 1960s, documented in Luca Cesari's history, not a tourist's mistake. This one is yolks only, no cream: if you want the older version, bear in mind that the white scrambles sooner.

  2. 2

    Pan or bowl

    Monosilio and SiCucina bring the sauce together in a steel bowl, not in the pan. Here it happens in the guanciale pan, off the heat; the bowl, with no flame underneath, is the forgiving route, for anyone afraid of scrambling the egg.

  3. 3

    How hot the egg sauce gets

    SiCucina puts the danger zone at 62 °C, other sources say never above 65, Cookist pasteurises the yolks at 65 and Monosilio at 52 in a bain-marie, that is with more time and less heat. Here the egg sauce is made off the heat, below 65 °C, because the yolk starts to set at around 63: the egg stays nearly raw, so for children, the elderly or during pregnancy use pasteurised eggs.

Where the numbers come from

This recipe compares 7 sources. The quantities are the median of the versions, not one person’s opinion: where the sources disagree, the majority wins. Here they all are.

Published , updated .

Allergens

  • Gluten
  • Eggs
  • Milk

They come from the recipe's list. The label on what you buy is what counts.

More recipes

The recipes

Coming to the App Store.

For 10min of this recipe’s 22min your hands are free: PREP tells you what to do meanwhile, and when to go back to the stove.

To hear when it’s out, write to francesco@preprecipe.com.

We count visits to the website without cookies and without knowing who you are.